American Buildout

Covering America’s infrastructure buildout.
UpdatedSaturday, November 21, 2026

Nuclear

‘Minimum Necessary’: NRC scales back safety advisory commission as U.S. races to nuclear expansion 

The unanimous vote takes away the power of a long-time advisory panel to weigh in on licenses and limits what it may and may not review. 

The Nuclear Regulatory Commission voted 5-0 Thursday to scale back the work of a 73-year-old committee of nuclear safety experts as it prepares to license a new generation of reactors.

 The rule ends the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards’ (ACRS) authority to open safety reviews on its own and removes automatic referrals of operating-license renewals. 

NRC Chairman Ho K. Nieh, an appointee of President Trump, said the commission’s vote “requires the NRC to reduce the personnel and functions of the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards to the minimum necessary to fulfill the ACRS’s statutory obligations and to focus the ACRS’s review of permitting and licensing issues on issues that are truly novel or noteworthy.”

The commission retains discretion to refer renewals and license amendments. Reports on new reactor applications will cover only novel or noteworthy issues within the committee’s scope. 

The direct final rule and companion proposal carry out Trump’s May 23, 2025, directive to reduce the committee’s personnel and functions to the minimum the law requires.

The ACRS was created during the Eisenhower administration, just as the U.S. was ramping up construction and licensing of nuclear reactors across the U.S. Congress gave it additional teeth following the 1979 accident at Three Mile Island – an accident that shocked the country and led to a partial meltdown of a reactor core.

“The ACRS’s objective expertise and independent scrutiny are more important than ever,” Commissioner Matthew J. Marzano, who was appointed by then-President Biden, said at Thursday’s public affirmation session. 

Marzano voted for the rule and backed focusing reviews on novel or noteworthy safety issues. He said the committee’s own guidance was sufficient to determine the scope of its reviews. Commissioner Bradley R. Crowell said he associated himself with Marzano’s remarks.

NRC Chairman Nieh said the rule would focus the committee’s expertise on novel and safety-significant issues and help the agency make timely, well-supported licensing decisions. 

The NRC’s announcement cited first-of-a-kind designs as one focus of review and tied the rule to tighter licensing deadlines. Committee meeting notices have reflected the executive order’s narrower focus since at least January 2026. The rule writes that part of current practice into regulation.

The committee reports directly to the commissioners, independently of the staff that evaluates applications.

The ACRS’ history is long and active when weighing in on nuclear safety issues.

In 1956, it found insufficient information to assure safe operation of Michigan’s Fermi 1 reactor. The Atomic Energy Commission issued a construction permit, treated the report as predecisional, and offered it to Congress only on condition it stay confidential. In 1957, Congress gave the committee statutory standing, required public release of its licensing reports and mandated hearings on all construction permits.

The committee raised the risk of a core meltdown in its 1965 reviews of Indian Point and Dresden nuclear plants. At its urging, the Atomic Energy Commission formed a task force on core meltdown in 1966. The task force concluded that emergency core cooling was central to protecting the public. 

After the 1979 Three Mile Island accident, the President’s Commission on the Accident at Three Mile Island called for strengthening the committee as “an independent technical check on safety matters.” It recommended ending compulsory review of every application and giving the committee the right to intervene in cases it chose and initiate rulemaking.

During the current Trump administration, the tech industry has been racing to build out its data center footprint across the U.S., with giants including Microsoft, Google and Meta cutting deals for nuclear power to supply either their data centers or the grid with more power. They found an ally in the current presidential administration.

President Trump’s Executive Order 14300 calls for expanding U.S. nuclear generating capacity from about 100 gigawatts to 400 by 2050. 

A companion order, Executive Order 14302, directs the Energy Department to prioritize work with industry to add 5 gigawatts at existing reactors and get 10 new large reactors with complete designs under construction by 2030.

Under its Three Mile Island action plan, the NRC adopted a rule in April 1981 that allowed the committee to recommend that the commission initiate rulemaking. It required a written response within 90 days and directed the NRC to place both the recommendation and the response in its Public Document Room. Thursday’s vote removes that authority and ends the committee’s reviews of reactor safety research every three years. Under the new rule, the committee’s advice on rules in development will focus on novel or noteworthy issues.

In 2020, the committee recommended certifying NuScale Power’s small modular reactor design with certain elements excluded from finality, including steam generator tube integrity. Committee member Vesna Dimitrijevic agreed with the technical conclusions and opposed issuing certification while the steam generator design lacked finality. In a 2021 letter, NuScale said the committee’s review took about 40 meetings and 440 hours. 

It said the review produced useful insights and called it unnecessarily broad and burdensome. NuScale proposed limiting committee review to safety-significant matters and requiring approval from the NRC’s executive director for operations for additional issues.

“If changes are not made the ACRS will constrain the deployment of advanced nuclear power,” the company told the NRC in that letter. 

The NRC’s analysis assumes five operating-license renewal applications a year. The agency’s renewal decision can give a reactor another 20 years of operation. The rule also ends automatic referrals for early site permit renewals. Constellation applied Nov. 4 to renew its Clinton, Illinois, early site permit, which expires March 15, 2027. That type of application requires referral under the existing rules. Constellation asked the agency to act by March 4, 2027.

The NRC estimates annualized savings of about $390,000 at a 7 percent discount rate. The agency says the committee normally allocates 87.5 hours to each renewal review. Dropping those reviews and the recurring safety research assessments accounts for most of the estimated savings.

As of Nov. 13, the notice had yet to appear in the Federal Register. Publication opens a 30-day public comment period. The rule is scheduled to take effect 75 days after publication unless the NRC receives a significant adverse comment. If it does, the agency will withdraw the direct final rule and address comments through the companion proposal. In January, the NRC withdrew an aircraft impact assessment provision from its Sunset Rule after receiving significant adverse comments. It reissued the provision in April after responding to those comments.

Federal law requires the committee to report on covered new reactor applications. The rule sets membership at seven to 15, with no fixed years-of-experience requirement. The committee had nine members over the past year. 

Committee and NRC staff leaders will jointly keep meeting agendas within the new scope. Before implementing the rule, staff must provide the commission with a revised agreement governing the committee’s work with the agency’s executive director for operations.

Share
Ad slot · in-article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

B